Director Alice Donahue has announced the cast:
 

Toffee Little - Emma Kyler

Candy - Kellie Morgan

Coco/Darla Darlington - Anna Kahle

Ginger - Abby Delong

Peaches - Norah Welly

Little Debbie - Catherine Myers

Sugar - Alexis Davis

Tootsie - Alexsei Jackson

Cookie/Stage Manager - Railee Ranshausen

Blondie/Shelia - Violet Shanks-Smith

Miss Strict - Madison Downing

Eddie Flagrante - Jon Allen

Jonny Warner - Justin Fleming

Jake - Wes Allen

Joey - Roswen Badertscher

Josh - Carson Caprella

Jasper - Alex Felter

Jimmy/Announcer - Tanner Koenig

Voice of Toffee’s Mother - Jodi Brincefield

Voice of Toffee’s Father - Christopher Butturff